"I was sitting about with my friend talking about dumb films we'd seen, dumb books we'd read and I said, 'I've got this idea for the dumbest alternate history book ever'. The next thing I knew I had the Americans on the phone throwing money at me."
Truer words were never
spoken. John Birmingham's dumbest book ever,
Weapons of Choice, took one of the most
awesome ridiculous movie premises ever, a US nuclear powered aircraft carrier mysterious
travelled through time to WWII, and took it to 11. I've never been so simultaneously insulted and entertained.
"Multinational task force" engaged in a 2021 War on Terror that looks like the wet dream of Ann Coulter and Mark Steyn? Check. Spooky experimental physics ship conducting wormhole experiments that go horribly wrong in a plot device that would make Michael Crichton barf? Got it. Ridiculous future technology married with wildly overoptimistic prediction of social trends? Not only do these guys have toys the Pentagon hasn't even dreamed of, one of the (US!) ship's captains is female, black,
and lesbian. Top off the absurdity by naming the aircraft carrier the
USS Hillary Clinton after "our most uncompromising war time president in history"? Yes, biatches, he did it. It makes bringing Prince Harry along as an SAS captain seem almost obvious in retrospect.
Despite (and sometimes because of) all that, it was a pretty good book. The man can write in that hair on fire, jumping around Clancy style dumb red meat eatin' Americans love, and hit some interesting sociological points, with the 2021 guys appalled by the bigotry of the "contemporaries" and they revolted by a future of all these darkies, dames, and queers running things. So despite the most appallingly unlikely series of events to make sure the newly reinforced Allies don't just wipe out the Axis in no time at all, you can't help but go along with it.
Alas, the second book,
Designated Targets, which I guiltily skimmed the other day, is much better and therefore makes me feel even more dirty for enjoying it. It's like Dumb and Dumber for right wing bloodthirsty techno-history geeks. And they agree - it's the first time I've seen the first 21 Amazon reviews of a book come in with a total of 103 stars.
It's got furious efforts by all sides to develop all this newfangled technology, race riots, J. Edgar Hoover pissed off at being outed, hundreds of traitors and spies on all sides being executed for being outed, some clever bad guys, some dumb good guys, and people who actually act like real people in entirely unreal situations. Intellectual property disputes (hey, we
would have developed it), celebrity cameos (JFK paints "The Grassy Knoll" on his PT boat, Elvis and Marilyn get signed up by a time travelling lawyer), and what-if war scenarios (Operation Sea Lion and a
really successful Japanese attack on Hawaii).
I found myself pretty impressed by a lot of things that would "really" happen that Birmingham put in, but most interested by the many dropped hints of the dark 2021 from which all of these wonderfully ridiculous people came from. Dirty bombs in Marseilles, European intifadas, punitive expeditions in every significant Middle Eastern country you'd care to name, mass slaughter and chaos all around, dogs and cats living together, etc.
Given all the Geneva Convention whining going on, it was fun to see Birmingham understand his audience and put in a newly elected President Hillary signing an executive order requiring US troops to execute in the field all enemies known to have committed violations of human rights. Due process? Some drone video footage and an officer's signature if you can be bothered. Hooah! Con: it stretched credibility that this sort of thing would really shock the folks who firebombed civilian populations. (I can well believe they'd be puzzled by the modern obsession with rescuing prisoners, though.) Pro: the ambiguous last line indicates the modern guys do something more than just shoot the fuckers in the head for the exceptionally bad cases. Punitive torture? Going after their families? I guess we'll find out in the next book.
Uh, if I'd read this sort of trash again, that is.
Update: Groan, the author
explains some of his jokes. I didn't realize the "Senator O'Reilly" mentioned as being a hardass in a committee hearing was
Bill O'Reilly.